Are businesses profiting from the process of establishing their identity theft response program? With the May 1st deadline fast approaching I found an article today that bears noting.
At a recent conference, an executive from a large creditor company told Betsy Broder, Assistant Director, Division of Privacy and Identity Protection at the Federal Trade Commission.
"This Red Flags rule was one of the best business exercises that his company had been through in years." The entire program's development forced the creditor to approach this issue in a much more logical, structured way, so that it now has one document that captured all of the company's fraud detection and response programs. "It made them approach it in a more holistic fashion," Broder says. "For that reason alone, they thought it was a beneficial exercise for them to go through."
I have written numerous pieces here and in other publications about the various benefits of having such a program. Companies can benefit in a number of ways from a culture shift as mentioned above, but also by training. At Taylor and Associates we focus on the benefit to the staff by providing a solid education of identity theft so they can better understand what we mean by identity theft. Not only what we see on television and the newspaper, but also the less understood and potentially more dangerous aspects of the crime. With this increased understanding employees are more apt to be proactive and protective with the files and information they handle on the job. Once armed with the knowledge of how identity theft can affect them and their families the more effective they are in joining the solution to combat identity theft.
These programs should be individually designed to bring each company into compliance with the law, but also to create the “culture of security” the FTC is trying to establish. This is most effective when management is committed to making the program work, and that all staff has been thoroughly oriented on their roles in implementing the program. Add to that the component of vendor oversight and you will have a healthy approach and response to the threat of data loss.
Tomorrow I will visit more of this article as we prepare to meet that May 1st deadline.
Monday, April 13, 2009
Monday, April 6, 2009
FTC Launches Red Flags Website
After a year or more of confusion on the part of businesses and their counsel the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has launched a Web site to help businesses and non-profits to come into compliance with the Red Flags Rules. The FTC will begin enforcing the rules on May 1. The site offers articles and guides for helping create identity theft prevention programs, a key requirement of the rules. The site also details which entities must adhere to the rules, which were created to reduce instances of identity theft. The FTC has also published a very good guide for businesses who must determine if they have “covered accounts” and how to go forward with their program. I have added a permanent link to the FTC Red Flags site to my links for your convenience.
Coming on the heels of the latest Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act (HITECH) which has sweeping new notification requirements, and was signed into law by the President Feb 17th as part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, it is now very clear that not only is the government going ahead with FACTA enforcement on May 1st, but is also addressing the varying discrepancies in state notification and reporting laws. The new federal notification law has a much lower threshold for reporting and will often constitute the rule for reporting breaches and the notification to all affected parties. Go to Ephemeralaw (link below), for a good overview of this new legislation.
Businesses need to take heed of these changes in the law and take the appropriate actions. Not doing so can result in serious penalties.
In spite of confusion and even resistance on the part of some companies it should be very clear that the paradigm has shifted regarding the protection of sensitive personal information. It is no longer possible to simply get by, every covered business must by law follow specific guidelines or face very serious consequences.
For any entity that identifies itself as needing to be in step with the FACTA Red Flags Rule Taylor and Associates provides a great deal of the framework for such a plan and policy including the employee training, documentation, and contractor/service provider oversight as well as an outline for an actual policy itself for identifying the red flags and a response plan. For any business who wishes more information about that program I can be contacted by way of my business website in the links portion of this column.
Coming on the heels of the latest Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health Act (HITECH) which has sweeping new notification requirements, and was signed into law by the President Feb 17th as part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, it is now very clear that not only is the government going ahead with FACTA enforcement on May 1st, but is also addressing the varying discrepancies in state notification and reporting laws. The new federal notification law has a much lower threshold for reporting and will often constitute the rule for reporting breaches and the notification to all affected parties. Go to Ephemeralaw (link below), for a good overview of this new legislation.
Businesses need to take heed of these changes in the law and take the appropriate actions. Not doing so can result in serious penalties.
In spite of confusion and even resistance on the part of some companies it should be very clear that the paradigm has shifted regarding the protection of sensitive personal information. It is no longer possible to simply get by, every covered business must by law follow specific guidelines or face very serious consequences.
For any entity that identifies itself as needing to be in step with the FACTA Red Flags Rule Taylor and Associates provides a great deal of the framework for such a plan and policy including the employee training, documentation, and contractor/service provider oversight as well as an outline for an actual policy itself for identifying the red flags and a response plan. For any business who wishes more information about that program I can be contacted by way of my business website in the links portion of this column.
Friday, April 3, 2009
Compliance with new Identity Theft legislation
This isn’t the first time I have written about the new Red Flags rule legislation, nor will it be the last apparently. It seems that a lot of business people want to weigh in on their own to declare proudly that they and their business are not covered by that law and to stop bugging them about it.
Here’s the rub with that. Unless you collect cash up front from all of your clients before rendering a service or product, and, have no employees, and do not have any financial relationships with individuals, your business, non-profit or local government agency is considered by the Federal Trade Commission to be covered. Now, my business is completely in step with this and other privacy laws so I really don’t care if your business is compliant or not. I do have the right however to refrain from doing business with you. I’m going to ask you to show me your policy program to prevent identity theft specifically in your company. If you can’t produce that document I will move on to another business. And I will advise everyone to do the same.
Its after May 1st and your business suffered a breach of information. You are required to notify everyone affected that you lost their information, and the federal auditors who will visit your firm are going to ask you to show them your identity theft plan. For your sake and that of your business I hope you can produce it.
Every few days in the last month or so I got an article or legal opinion from a different industry group advising their member businesses that they should be compliant prior to May 1st. Today it was the American Veterinary Medical Association. Last week it was the AM News, the news source for the AMA, the American Dental Association, and a state BAR. The legal profession is among the worst. I’m convinced that you can find General Counsel who will say almost anything the boss wants to hear. I can’t tell you how many GCs have told me outright that their companies don’t have to be concerned with these laws only to find out by actually reading the Act and seeking opinion from privacy specialists that they were wrong. Not to impugn the legal business but why do so many practicing attorneys take the automatic position that someone else is wrong on a subject they themselves know very little about? Pride is a dangerous thing when it is applied to business.
I don't mean to single out lawyers, they are not alone by a long shot. I had a nationally prominent accountancy and investment wealth advisory tell me outright that the FTC had absolutely no oversight of his industry! This finger pointing to the other guy, half-cocked opinions, and squirming leaves me to wonder. “What are these guys all afraid of?”
Now, this might not seem like the most pressing issue of the day to a lot of folks, but to the millions of victims of identity theft it is. And after looking at the penalties that have already been imposed on businesses that have suffered breaches, along with court actions on the part of victims no business wants that kind of liability. I have yet to find a business owner who has been victimized or knows someone who has that is reluctant to initiate an identity theft program for his or her business.
Its April 3rd, 27 days isn’t very long to get your act together
Here’s the rub with that. Unless you collect cash up front from all of your clients before rendering a service or product, and, have no employees, and do not have any financial relationships with individuals, your business, non-profit or local government agency is considered by the Federal Trade Commission to be covered. Now, my business is completely in step with this and other privacy laws so I really don’t care if your business is compliant or not. I do have the right however to refrain from doing business with you. I’m going to ask you to show me your policy program to prevent identity theft specifically in your company. If you can’t produce that document I will move on to another business. And I will advise everyone to do the same.
Its after May 1st and your business suffered a breach of information. You are required to notify everyone affected that you lost their information, and the federal auditors who will visit your firm are going to ask you to show them your identity theft plan. For your sake and that of your business I hope you can produce it.
Every few days in the last month or so I got an article or legal opinion from a different industry group advising their member businesses that they should be compliant prior to May 1st. Today it was the American Veterinary Medical Association. Last week it was the AM News, the news source for the AMA, the American Dental Association, and a state BAR. The legal profession is among the worst. I’m convinced that you can find General Counsel who will say almost anything the boss wants to hear. I can’t tell you how many GCs have told me outright that their companies don’t have to be concerned with these laws only to find out by actually reading the Act and seeking opinion from privacy specialists that they were wrong. Not to impugn the legal business but why do so many practicing attorneys take the automatic position that someone else is wrong on a subject they themselves know very little about? Pride is a dangerous thing when it is applied to business.
I don't mean to single out lawyers, they are not alone by a long shot. I had a nationally prominent accountancy and investment wealth advisory tell me outright that the FTC had absolutely no oversight of his industry! This finger pointing to the other guy, half-cocked opinions, and squirming leaves me to wonder. “What are these guys all afraid of?”
Now, this might not seem like the most pressing issue of the day to a lot of folks, but to the millions of victims of identity theft it is. And after looking at the penalties that have already been imposed on businesses that have suffered breaches, along with court actions on the part of victims no business wants that kind of liability. I have yet to find a business owner who has been victimized or knows someone who has that is reluctant to initiate an identity theft program for his or her business.
Its April 3rd, 27 days isn’t very long to get your act together
Monday, March 30, 2009
If You Are Me Then Who Am I?
If You Are Me Then Who Am I? The personal and business reality of identity theft
I know I posted a recommendation for this book recently but it bears mentioning again. This book does a good job explaining just where we are with identity theft legislation, what we can do as individuals to protect ourselves, the steps most victims usually encounter when they are trying to go it alone to set the records straight, how the law works (or doesn’t work), and how smart businesses can fight the bleeding of sensitive information from their companies. There is an intersection where privacy law, privacy rights, and identity theft merge. This is really at the crux of what identity theft has become and how it affects us as individuals in more ways than we thought. If You Are Me delves into that rather sticky subject with the same objectivity that they treat the other topics they cover. Seeing the scenarios as they might play themselves out helps you to understand just how critical records accuracy is.
I chose early on to concentrate this column to business related topics. The subject is simply too vast for most mortals to tackle, but not the authors of this book. I recommend it to any privacy professional simply because it will shake up some preconceived notions we all have when our work is focused and rather narrow.The authors of this book have laid out in plain terms what the state of identity theft is right now, and where we have come in the past several years. No one can claim to know what will happen in the future of fighting identity theft so this book takes the intelligent approach of trying to prepare us with information and other tools.
Besides privacy specialists, anyone who thinks they know about identity theft and data loss should read it too.
Bravo to the authors!
Remember, “When you protect the information you keep on others you are protecting them. When someone else does it they are protecting you.”
I know I posted a recommendation for this book recently but it bears mentioning again. This book does a good job explaining just where we are with identity theft legislation, what we can do as individuals to protect ourselves, the steps most victims usually encounter when they are trying to go it alone to set the records straight, how the law works (or doesn’t work), and how smart businesses can fight the bleeding of sensitive information from their companies. There is an intersection where privacy law, privacy rights, and identity theft merge. This is really at the crux of what identity theft has become and how it affects us as individuals in more ways than we thought. If You Are Me delves into that rather sticky subject with the same objectivity that they treat the other topics they cover. Seeing the scenarios as they might play themselves out helps you to understand just how critical records accuracy is.
I chose early on to concentrate this column to business related topics. The subject is simply too vast for most mortals to tackle, but not the authors of this book. I recommend it to any privacy professional simply because it will shake up some preconceived notions we all have when our work is focused and rather narrow.The authors of this book have laid out in plain terms what the state of identity theft is right now, and where we have come in the past several years. No one can claim to know what will happen in the future of fighting identity theft so this book takes the intelligent approach of trying to prepare us with information and other tools.
Besides privacy specialists, anyone who thinks they know about identity theft and data loss should read it too.
Bravo to the authors!
Remember, “When you protect the information you keep on others you are protecting them. When someone else does it they are protecting you.”
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
Compliance? Fugeddaboutit!
In my work of helping businesses to meet standards of compliance with FACTA and GLB requirements I constantly run into lazy attitudes regarding encryption, and basic steps like not recycling photo copies with sensitive data on them, lock files away, and so forth. For example, I was in a bank recently giving a talk on how data is stolen, and in the office area where I was speaking the Chief Loan Officer had his computer monitor facing the street by way of a huge picture window only 5 feet away. And in plain view of the public walking by!
The bottom line for me is pretty simple. Given the attitude on the part of businesses of all types and sizes, the massive holes in the PCI DSS and state notification legislation, why is everyone wringing their hands wondering what to do? Get a real (read professional), identity theft service that will actually help you when you need it, and largely put the issue to rest. This is not to say that we can stop pursuing compliance on the part of business. That is going to take a lot longer than necessary due to the reluctance of business to comply with some simple procedures. The problem for us is that identity thieves aren't going to wait. This set of crimes is increasing every year, and shows no signs of slowing down. I am addressing what we as individuals can do right now to protect ourselves proactively.
In 2001 I was a victim of identity theft that cost me over $26,000 dollars to solve, (is it really solved? I don't know), and 2 + years of agony. I can say without reservation that if I had the service I have now it wouldn't have cost me one dime more than my service. Not so incidentally $26,000 is over 18 years of my identity theft service, and it protects both my wife and me. Is that a cost effective service? I think so.
Now we are facing the Electronic Records Initiative as part of the economic recovery package. This is designed to compile all of our medical records in "cloud" servers available to, well, almost everyone. While this can be a massive cost savings to the health care industry, and potentially a great advantage for the individual when we seek medical help or prescriptions, it also opens a whole new set of security problems to solve. Medical identity theft is the fastest growing category of identity theft, and potentially the most dangerous. It can cost you your life. When will Americans wake up and realize that identity theft is a vast subject and a simple fraud alert or monitoring service will not help? And waiting to be a victim so your employer will buy you a year of free monitoring is not very smart either. We all need to take the initiative ourselves and stop our victim mentality.
How long did it take business to install ramps for people who needed them? ADA has been around for decades and we are still fighting that one. What makes anyone think this will be any different? Surely there are laws with very stiff penalties but mere laws won’t stop a good old American business from ignoring the facts. Even when this is presented as the right thing to do, appealing to a business owners’ sense of right and wrong a lot of them still don’t get it. Legislation is seen as an invasion to a business owner regardless of the nature of the law and it’s intention. It's an automatic reaction. The brain reels at the idea of compliance, a signal is sent throughout the body and, voila! Knee jerk! They see this as something they have to do for someone else that just gets in the way. I have often said that when you protect the information you keep on others you are protecting them. When someone else does it they are protecting you. Any business owner who has been a victim of identity theft does not have to be convinced that these laws are worthwhile. In fact in my experience they are eager to develop a plan to protect information, and are looking for guidance as to implementing such a plan.
Until such a time when all business and users of personal information take data security seriously we as the public need to take the initiative to safeguard ourselves. Don’t wait for them; it is a dangerous game with very high stakes for you. And without a good restorative service to be your advocate you will be left largely alone to suffer the misery of trying to fight the system in clearing your name and records.
The bottom line for me is pretty simple. Given the attitude on the part of businesses of all types and sizes, the massive holes in the PCI DSS and state notification legislation, why is everyone wringing their hands wondering what to do? Get a real (read professional), identity theft service that will actually help you when you need it, and largely put the issue to rest. This is not to say that we can stop pursuing compliance on the part of business. That is going to take a lot longer than necessary due to the reluctance of business to comply with some simple procedures. The problem for us is that identity thieves aren't going to wait. This set of crimes is increasing every year, and shows no signs of slowing down. I am addressing what we as individuals can do right now to protect ourselves proactively.
In 2001 I was a victim of identity theft that cost me over $26,000 dollars to solve, (is it really solved? I don't know), and 2 + years of agony. I can say without reservation that if I had the service I have now it wouldn't have cost me one dime more than my service. Not so incidentally $26,000 is over 18 years of my identity theft service, and it protects both my wife and me. Is that a cost effective service? I think so.
Now we are facing the Electronic Records Initiative as part of the economic recovery package. This is designed to compile all of our medical records in "cloud" servers available to, well, almost everyone. While this can be a massive cost savings to the health care industry, and potentially a great advantage for the individual when we seek medical help or prescriptions, it also opens a whole new set of security problems to solve. Medical identity theft is the fastest growing category of identity theft, and potentially the most dangerous. It can cost you your life. When will Americans wake up and realize that identity theft is a vast subject and a simple fraud alert or monitoring service will not help? And waiting to be a victim so your employer will buy you a year of free monitoring is not very smart either. We all need to take the initiative ourselves and stop our victim mentality.
How long did it take business to install ramps for people who needed them? ADA has been around for decades and we are still fighting that one. What makes anyone think this will be any different? Surely there are laws with very stiff penalties but mere laws won’t stop a good old American business from ignoring the facts. Even when this is presented as the right thing to do, appealing to a business owners’ sense of right and wrong a lot of them still don’t get it. Legislation is seen as an invasion to a business owner regardless of the nature of the law and it’s intention. It's an automatic reaction. The brain reels at the idea of compliance, a signal is sent throughout the body and, voila! Knee jerk! They see this as something they have to do for someone else that just gets in the way. I have often said that when you protect the information you keep on others you are protecting them. When someone else does it they are protecting you. Any business owner who has been a victim of identity theft does not have to be convinced that these laws are worthwhile. In fact in my experience they are eager to develop a plan to protect information, and are looking for guidance as to implementing such a plan.
Until such a time when all business and users of personal information take data security seriously we as the public need to take the initiative to safeguard ourselves. Don’t wait for them; it is a dangerous game with very high stakes for you. And without a good restorative service to be your advocate you will be left largely alone to suffer the misery of trying to fight the system in clearing your name and records.
Red Flag rules Deadline May 1st
This morning William Morriss who is co-author of the blog Ephemeralaw, made the following post written by his colleagues Jane Shea and Gretchen Ackerman, (see links).
I cannot find a way to improve on the research and work they have done so I have obtained permission to post the article as published. As the controversy swirls about like a hot potato the May 1st deadline is fast approaching. I think one of the saddest aspects of this is that the individual is lost in the argument. And it is the individual that is supposed to be protected by these new rules. Compliance doesn’t have to hurt, and for most every business it need not be a financial burden. In the words of Kirk Nahra, a noted expert in privacy law. “It’s the right thing to do.” Once again, here is a solid article written by professionals, and aimed at businesses in America as a wake up call. For more from Ephemeralaw there is a link to their writings in my links below.
Thank you William, Jane, and Gretchen
Red Flag Rules - Deadline May 1
My colleagues Jane Shea and Gretchen Ackerman have published a new business advisory on the FTC red flag rules. I am posting it here with permission.The May 1, 2009 deadline for creating and implementing an Identity Theft Protection and Prevention Program required by FTC Rules is fast approaching. The Identity Theft Red Flag Rules apply to all organizations with accounts primarily for personal, family or household purposes that permit multiple payments. Creditors subject to these rules include utilities, retailers, local governments, and car dealers, if such organizations carry consumer accounts permitting multiple repayments. Many hospitals and patient care facilities extend credit to patients for deferred payment of treatment costs. These health care entities must implement an Identity Theft Protection and Prevention Program to identify, detect and respond to the possible existence of identity theft with respect to these accounts. Health care entities must also take care to ensure that these programs do not conflict with other Federal and State laws, rules and regulations such as EMTALA. The FTC Rules require all such organizations to develop and implement a proactive identity theft prevention program, and provide detailed guidelines intended to provide assistance in creating such a program. Financial institutions regulated by a regulatory agency other than the FTC were required to adopt and implement an Identity Theft Protection and Prevention Program no later than November 1, 2008. Federal regulators were required by the FACT Act of 2003 to issue regulations that implement Section 114 of the Act, which amended the Fair Credit Reporting Act to require financial institutions and other creditors which maintain consumer accounts to adopt and maintain a written Identity Theft Prevention Program to detect, prevent, and mitigate identity theft in connection with the opening of accounts maintained for personal, family or household purposes, so long as the accounts permit multiple payments or transactions. Examples include credit card accounts, patient deferred payment plans, mortgage loans, automobile loans, margin accounts, cell phone accounts, utility accounts, checking accounts or savings accounts.The regulations provide organizations subject to the Rules with flexibility in developing their programs according to their relative size and complexity. However, the Program must include reasonable policies and procedures that:identify relevant Red Flags, and then incorporate those Red Flags into the Program; detect such Red Flags; respond appropriately to any Red Flags to prevent and mitigate identity theft; and ensure that the Program is updated periodically to reflect changes in risks to customers What are the "Red Flags"? The regulations define them as a "pattern, practice, or specific activity that indicates the possible existence of identity theft." However, the concept is fleshed out considerably in the supplementary materials to the regulations. The federal regulatory agencies have adopted Interagency Guidelines on Identity Theft Detection, Prevention, and Mitigation. The Regulations include a section explaining the relationship of the rules to the guidelines, specifically, that each financial institution or creditor must consider the guidelines in developing its Program, and must include those Guidelines that are appropriate. They provide policies and procedures that can be used, where appropriate, to satisfy the regulatory requirements of the Rules. Thus, the Guidelines provide with respect to risk factors an organization should consider in identifying red flags, likely sources of red flags, and categories of red flags that should be included in the Program. Additionally, the supplementary materials to the Guidelines include illustrative examples of Red Flags which may be incorporated into a Program, and break these down into five categories: 1) Alerts, Notifications or Warnings from a Consumer Reporting Agency; 2) Suspicious Documents; 3) Suspicious Personal Identifying Information; 4) Unusual Use of, or Suspicious Activity Related to, the Covered Account; and 5) Notice from Customers, Victims of Identity Theft, Law Enforcement Authorities, or Others Regarding Possible Identity Theft in Connection with Covered Accounts Held by the Financial Institution or Creditor. Examples include:a fraud or active duty alert is included with a consumer report a consumer reporting agency provides a notice of credit freeze in response to a request for a consumer report a consumer reporting agency provides a notice of address discrepancy identification documents appear to be forged inconsistencies between identification provided and the consumer's/patient's appearance or the information actually provided by the consumer/patient inconsistencies between personally identifying information provided and that obtained from external information sources a new revolving credit account is used in a manner commonly associated with known patterns of fraud.Once the Program has been established, the organization must administer the Program, and not simply place it on a shelf. This involves requiring that the board of directors or an appropriate committee of the Board approve the initial written Program, and that the Board, an appropriate Board committee, or a designated member of senior management be responsible for the oversight, development, implementation and administration of the Program. Additionally, training of relevant staff and effective oversight of third party service providers with respect to the Program is also required. Organizations covered by the Red Flag Identity Theft Rules are subject to oversight by the appropriate federal regulators, and for those creditors that are not federally regulated financial institutions, the Federal Trade Commission provides oversight. Besides regulatory enforcement actions, violations of the FACT Act can subject an organization to civil actions for damages. The type and amount of damages available will depend on whether the violations are "negligent" or "willful." For a claim for negligent violation, a plaintiff must prove he or she suffered actual harm as a result of the defendant's negligence. In the case of a claim for a willful violation, most courts will require proof of actual knowledge and intentional violation of the relevant statute by the organization.
I cannot find a way to improve on the research and work they have done so I have obtained permission to post the article as published. As the controversy swirls about like a hot potato the May 1st deadline is fast approaching. I think one of the saddest aspects of this is that the individual is lost in the argument. And it is the individual that is supposed to be protected by these new rules. Compliance doesn’t have to hurt, and for most every business it need not be a financial burden. In the words of Kirk Nahra, a noted expert in privacy law. “It’s the right thing to do.” Once again, here is a solid article written by professionals, and aimed at businesses in America as a wake up call. For more from Ephemeralaw there is a link to their writings in my links below.
Thank you William, Jane, and Gretchen
Red Flag Rules - Deadline May 1
My colleagues Jane Shea and Gretchen Ackerman have published a new business advisory on the FTC red flag rules. I am posting it here with permission.The May 1, 2009 deadline for creating and implementing an Identity Theft Protection and Prevention Program required by FTC Rules is fast approaching. The Identity Theft Red Flag Rules apply to all organizations with accounts primarily for personal, family or household purposes that permit multiple payments. Creditors subject to these rules include utilities, retailers, local governments, and car dealers, if such organizations carry consumer accounts permitting multiple repayments. Many hospitals and patient care facilities extend credit to patients for deferred payment of treatment costs. These health care entities must implement an Identity Theft Protection and Prevention Program to identify, detect and respond to the possible existence of identity theft with respect to these accounts. Health care entities must also take care to ensure that these programs do not conflict with other Federal and State laws, rules and regulations such as EMTALA. The FTC Rules require all such organizations to develop and implement a proactive identity theft prevention program, and provide detailed guidelines intended to provide assistance in creating such a program. Financial institutions regulated by a regulatory agency other than the FTC were required to adopt and implement an Identity Theft Protection and Prevention Program no later than November 1, 2008. Federal regulators were required by the FACT Act of 2003 to issue regulations that implement Section 114 of the Act, which amended the Fair Credit Reporting Act to require financial institutions and other creditors which maintain consumer accounts to adopt and maintain a written Identity Theft Prevention Program to detect, prevent, and mitigate identity theft in connection with the opening of accounts maintained for personal, family or household purposes, so long as the accounts permit multiple payments or transactions. Examples include credit card accounts, patient deferred payment plans, mortgage loans, automobile loans, margin accounts, cell phone accounts, utility accounts, checking accounts or savings accounts.The regulations provide organizations subject to the Rules with flexibility in developing their programs according to their relative size and complexity. However, the Program must include reasonable policies and procedures that:identify relevant Red Flags, and then incorporate those Red Flags into the Program; detect such Red Flags; respond appropriately to any Red Flags to prevent and mitigate identity theft; and ensure that the Program is updated periodically to reflect changes in risks to customers What are the "Red Flags"? The regulations define them as a "pattern, practice, or specific activity that indicates the possible existence of identity theft." However, the concept is fleshed out considerably in the supplementary materials to the regulations. The federal regulatory agencies have adopted Interagency Guidelines on Identity Theft Detection, Prevention, and Mitigation. The Regulations include a section explaining the relationship of the rules to the guidelines, specifically, that each financial institution or creditor must consider the guidelines in developing its Program, and must include those Guidelines that are appropriate. They provide policies and procedures that can be used, where appropriate, to satisfy the regulatory requirements of the Rules. Thus, the Guidelines provide with respect to risk factors an organization should consider in identifying red flags, likely sources of red flags, and categories of red flags that should be included in the Program. Additionally, the supplementary materials to the Guidelines include illustrative examples of Red Flags which may be incorporated into a Program, and break these down into five categories: 1) Alerts, Notifications or Warnings from a Consumer Reporting Agency; 2) Suspicious Documents; 3) Suspicious Personal Identifying Information; 4) Unusual Use of, or Suspicious Activity Related to, the Covered Account; and 5) Notice from Customers, Victims of Identity Theft, Law Enforcement Authorities, or Others Regarding Possible Identity Theft in Connection with Covered Accounts Held by the Financial Institution or Creditor. Examples include:a fraud or active duty alert is included with a consumer report a consumer reporting agency provides a notice of credit freeze in response to a request for a consumer report a consumer reporting agency provides a notice of address discrepancy identification documents appear to be forged inconsistencies between identification provided and the consumer's/patient's appearance or the information actually provided by the consumer/patient inconsistencies between personally identifying information provided and that obtained from external information sources a new revolving credit account is used in a manner commonly associated with known patterns of fraud.Once the Program has been established, the organization must administer the Program, and not simply place it on a shelf. This involves requiring that the board of directors or an appropriate committee of the Board approve the initial written Program, and that the Board, an appropriate Board committee, or a designated member of senior management be responsible for the oversight, development, implementation and administration of the Program. Additionally, training of relevant staff and effective oversight of third party service providers with respect to the Program is also required. Organizations covered by the Red Flag Identity Theft Rules are subject to oversight by the appropriate federal regulators, and for those creditors that are not federally regulated financial institutions, the Federal Trade Commission provides oversight. Besides regulatory enforcement actions, violations of the FACT Act can subject an organization to civil actions for damages. The type and amount of damages available will depend on whether the violations are "negligent" or "willful." For a claim for negligent violation, a plaintiff must prove he or she suffered actual harm as a result of the defendant's negligence. In the case of a claim for a willful violation, most courts will require proof of actual knowledge and intentional violation of the relevant statute by the organization.
Monday, March 23, 2009
A New Link
I am proud to add a new link to this blog site. John Gardner has been a professional friend and consultant for several years. John, or perhaps his wife and partner Elizabeth once coined a phrase. "It's hard being right.....early" When in 2005 they predicted against all odds (and some ridicule), that medical identity theft was going to be a major problem. Less than 3 years later medical identity theft has indeed become a very serious problem with millions of victims.....so far.
John co-authored a very comprehensive new book on identity theft from both the perspectives of individuals and business owners. Titled "If You Are Me Then Who Am I? the personal and business reality of identity theft." This book goes much further into the subject of identity theft and data loss than any previous book available to the public.
Additionally, John has begun his own website and commentary. For his opinions and positions please go to his site listed in my links.
John co-authored a very comprehensive new book on identity theft from both the perspectives of individuals and business owners. Titled "If You Are Me Then Who Am I? the personal and business reality of identity theft." This book goes much further into the subject of identity theft and data loss than any previous book available to the public.
Additionally, John has begun his own website and commentary. For his opinions and positions please go to his site listed in my links.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

